Blue Jackets vs. Islanders: Can Columbus Survive the Second Period?

Columbus had a two-goal lead Saturday and still couldn’t stop its losing streak. The Islanders turned their own second period into a four-goal burst and a comfortable win. That’s the question connecting these teams: can the Blue Jackets get through the middle of this game without handing New York the opening it needs?

Columbus needs more than a good start

Dmitri Voronkov and Matthew Knies scored just over a minute apart to put Columbus ahead 2-0 against Philadelphia. Adam Fantilli later tied the game, but the Blue Jackets still lost 4-3 to the Flyers. Their fourth straight defeat wasn’t simply a night when the offense failed to show up. A second-period goal off a steal and another on Philadelphia’s power play erased the early advantage.

Columbus has been outscored 25-9 in second periods through 18 games. Against an Islanders team coming off a huge middle frame, the Blue Jackets need cleaner exits and fewer possessions that end with them defending again. They’ve scored only seven goals across their four consecutive losses, so repeatedly asking the offense to repair those breakdowns hasn’t worked.

They’re also dealing with Sean Monahan's absence with an upper-body injury. Luca Del Bel Belluz replaced him against Philadelphia and recorded an assist. That’s an encouraging contribution, but it doesn’t erase the need for Fantilli and the rest of the attack to turn an early scoring burst into sustained pressure.

New York has scoring momentum to test

Simon Holmstrom’s first career hat trick and Matthew Schaefer’s three assists drove the Islanders’ 6-2 win over Anaheim. Bo Horvat opened the four-goal second period with a one-timer from the slot, and Schaefer later supplied the pass for Mitchell Chaffee’s goal. New York followed a 5-2 win over Los Angeles with another game in which several players helped build the attack.

That gives the Islanders a concrete way to challenge Columbus: keep possessions alive long enough to find the next pass rather than rely on the first shot. But the two wins followed four straight losses. The recent scoring is a reason to watch, not yet proof that New York has solved its offensive inconsistency.

Moneyline: how much separation is there?

DraftKings lists the Islanders at -142 and the Blue Jackets at +120, with a total of 5.5. New York’s case at that price starts with Columbus’ defensive mistakes and the potential advantage in net, rather than an expectation that the Islanders will dominate possession.

Neither listed goalie is confirmed. If they start, Ilya Sorokin brings a .911 save percentage across his five most recent appearances, compared with Jet Greaves' .867 over his latest five. Sorokin stopped 26 of 28 shots against Los Angeles in his last appearance; Greaves stopped 17 of 21 against Philadelphia. That recent contrast matters in a matchup where a handful of saves could separate the teams.

We expect roughly 28 shots apiece, so there’s little projected shot-volume separation to justify treating New York as a runaway favorite. Paying its price calls for confidence that the Islanders can turn Columbus turnovers into offense while getting the steadier goaltending. Columbus’ plus-money case gets stronger if it protects the puck and makes New York create against an organized defense. A change in either goalie assignment would warrant another look before taking the quoted price.

Total: a quiet shot count can still produce six goals

The case for scoring above 5.5 comes from the mistakes, not overwhelming shot volume. Columbus just conceded four goals on 21 shots against Philadelphia, while New York has scored 11 times in two games. Another turnover that opens the slot or a power-play breakdown could make a fairly even game much more productive on the scoreboard.

The counterargument is Sorokin’s ability to hold down Columbus and the Blue Jackets’ recent difficulty scoring. Our shot expectations don’t point to a barrage at either end. For the under to look attractive, Columbus needs to remove the easy follow-up possessions and force New York to work for its offense. For the over, the useful question is whether the Islanders’ recent passing sequences can expose the same defensive lapses Philadelphia punished—not whether New York can repeat a six-goal night.

Watch what happens after the first intermission

Keep an eye on Columbus’ first few exits in the second period and whether Horvat’s group can turn extended possessions into passes through the slot. That’s where the Blue Jackets’ biggest recurring problem meets New York’s latest success. Visit the NHL betting board to compare this matchup’s prices with the rest of the slate, especially if the goalie assignments change.

Odds and projections are snapshots and can change. Wagering involves risk.

Follow Sharpest Bets

FREE PREMIUM PREVIEW

Unlock our Premium picks. Free.

Get our sharpest picks, team grades, and projected score in your inbox.

Welcome back