There’s almost nothing separating these teams in the moneyline market, which puts the focus on the details that can swing a close game: sustained pressure, clean puck possession and avoiding the penalties that hand a dangerous top unit an extra opportunity.
The moneyline leaves little room for error
The latest moneyline odds have Buffalo at -112 and Columbus at -108, effectively pricing the game as a toss-up. Our team grades tell a similar story: both clubs carry a B- overall grade, with a B for offense and a C+ for defense.
The differences are subtle but useful. Our team projections put Columbus at about 30 shots and Buffalo at roughly 29, and the Blue Jackets hold a modest edge in expected faceoff wins. Buffalo projects as the more physical side, with about 21 hits compared with 19 for Columbus, while the Sabres are expected to generate roughly three power-play opportunities.
Both top groups can create pressure
Buffalo can build its attack around Tage Thompson, Josh Norris and Josh Doan, with Rasmus Dahlin adding another puck-moving threat from the blue line. The Sabres’ official preview also highlighted Mattias Samuelsson’s expected return, giving Buffalo another important presence alongside Dahlin.
Columbus counters with Adam Fantilli between Matthew Knies and Kent Johnson, while Zach Werenski remains central to the pressure the Blue Jackets can create from the back end. That group gives Columbus a plausible route to controlling more of the puck, especially if its projected faceoff advantage produces additional possession.
Sharpest Bets Premium
Get our Sabres vs. Blue Jackets picks.
Unlock our model's best bets for this matchup, plus projections, trends, and matchup analysis. Start with a free 7-day trial, then save 20% every month with code PREVIEW20.
The scoring environment deserves a closer look
The total is 6.5, with the under priced at -135. Our four-star total rating is stronger than the two-star moneyline rating, making the overall scoring environment a more substantial part of the analysis than trying to force broad separation between two closely matched teams.
Last season’s closing form points in different directions. Buffalo went 5-5 over its final 10 games, with six finishing over their posted totals. Columbus went 2-8 over its last 10, and six stayed under. Those games came under different competitive circumstances, so the splits work better as background than as a clean trend for a new season.
The shot projections aren’t extreme in either direction, but discipline could change the pace quickly. Buffalo projects for a little more than four penalties, compared with roughly three for Columbus. In a game with such narrow moneyline pricing, giving either power play extra chances could outweigh the small differences in the five-on-five profile.
Final assessment
Buffalo’s case rests on its physical edge, the possibility of generating more power-play opportunities and a top group capable of converting limited openings. Columbus answers with home ice and slight projected advantages in shots and faceoffs. With matching overall grades and almost even pricing, the team that protects possession and stays out of the penalty box is best positioned to create the separation the broader numbers don’t provide.
We break down every matchup
For sharp picks, current odds, model projections and matchup ratings across the league, visit our NHL betting board.
Odds and projections are snapshots and can change. Wagering involves risk.
