Milwaukee has built a convincing case as the stronger team, from its 101-win record to an impressive late-season run. The more interesting question for bettors is whether that gap is wide enough to justify a substantial moneyline price against a St. Louis club that showed plenty of power in Friday’s series opener.
Milwaukee’s advantage is clear, but not absolute
The Brewers enter at 101-59, while the Cardinals are 77-83. Our grades reinforce that separation: Milwaukee owns an A- lineup grade, a B pitching grade and a B overall mark. St. Louis comes in with a C lineup, C+ pitching and a C+ overall grade.
Recent results tell a similar story. Milwaukee has won eight of its last 10 games, while St. Louis has dropped seven of 10. In Milwaukee’s 8-4 win Friday, Brice Turang collected three hits and broke a tie with a two-run single in the eighth inning. The Cardinals still offered a useful reminder of their upset path: Iván Herrera, Jordan Walker and Alec Burleson all homered, and St. Louis erased a three-run deficit before Milwaukee pulled away.
That power matters because the Brewers’ broader edge doesn’t mean every inning will be comfortable. If St. Louis can create quick damage and avoid asking its bullpen to navigate repeated traffic, it has a plausible route to keeping the game close.
Mathews and May make this more interesting
Quinn Mathews starts for St. Louis opposite Dustin May. Mathews enters with a 2-3 record and 3.65 ERA, while May is 7-9 with a 4.87 ERA. That makes the starting-pitching matchup less lopsided than the teams’ overall records might suggest.
Our projections also show a relatively modest statistical gap at the plate. Both clubs project for about eight hits, with Milwaukee holding smaller advantages in total bases and walks. We project roughly 13 total bases and four walks for the Brewers, compared with about 12 total bases and three walks for the Cardinals. That supports Milwaukee’s deeper overall profile, but it leaves room for a competitive game if Mathews limits free passes and the Cardinals convert their extra-base opportunities.
Sharpest Bets Premium
Get our Cardinals vs. Brewers picks.
Unlock our model's best bets for this matchup, plus projections, trends, and matchup analysis. Start with a free 7-day trial, then save 20% every month with code PREVIEW20.
What the moneyline price is asking
The latest DraftKings odds make Milwaukee a -163 moneyline favorite. The Brewers’ record, recent form and stronger lineup grade explain why they’re favored, but the price asks a more demanding question than which team is likelier to win: is Milwaukee’s advantage large enough to justify the cost?
The total sits at 7.5, but recent scoring results don’t supply much direction. Each club has produced five overs and five unders across its last 10 games. The more useful scoring question is whether Mathews can limit Milwaukee’s traffic and whether the Cardinals’ power can again compensate for their thinner overall offensive profile.
Final assessment
Milwaukee brings the strongest overall case: a much better season record, an 8-2 recent stretch and superior grades across its lineup and pitching. St. Louis’ counterweight is Mathews and a lineup that just demonstrated how quickly it can change a game with one swing. The factor that matters most is whether the Brewers can consistently create baserunners against Mathews rather than depending on another late breakthrough.
We break down every matchup
For more games, visit our MLB betting board to explore sharp picks, current odds, model projections and matchup ratings across the league.
Odds and projections are snapshots and can change. Wagering involves risk.
