Buffalo has the cleaner profile entering this AFC East matchup, but laying a full touchdown asks a sharper question than simply choosing the more likely winner. The Bills are 3-0 and averaging an NFL-best 33.7 points, while New England is 1-2 and tied for last at 12 points per game, based on the teams’ early-season scoring rates. The handicap turns on whether Buffalo’s ground game can create enough separation—and whether either quarterback can avoid another messy turnover day.
Buffalo’s clearest edge may be on the ground
Buffalo’s latest result showed both its upside and its vulnerability. The Bills beat the Chargers 24-16 despite committing five turnovers, with James Cook rushing for 154 yards and Josh Allen scoring twice on the ground. Allen also threw two interceptions, leaving the defense to repeatedly protect short fields.
Our projections make the running game the clearest statistical separator. Buffalo lands around 371 total yards, including 152 on the ground, while New England projects for roughly 341 total yards and 120 rushing yards. The passing estimates are nearly even—about 222 yards for the Patriots and 219 for the Bills—so Buffalo’s expected advantage comes largely from what it can produce without leaning exclusively on Allen’s arm.
DJ Moore’s shoulder status is the main current availability question in Buffalo’s receiving group. He is questionable, and Sal Capaccio of WGR reported that Moore returned to Friday’s practice in a red non-contact jersey. That’s worth monitoring if Buffalo has to lean more heavily on the passing game.
New England needs a much cleaner game from Drake Maye
The Patriots are coming off a 35-6 loss in Jacksonville in which Maye threw two interceptions and fumbled twice, losing one. One interception came in goal-to-go territory, and another gave Jacksonville a short field. Against a Buffalo team capable of controlling the ball with Cook and Allen, New England’s most direct path to a competitive fourth quarter starts with avoiding those possession-changing mistakes.
The Patriots don’t necessarily need to match Buffalo’s rushing production snap for snap. They do need Maye to keep the offense on schedule, finish the limited scoring chances that appear and avoid handing the Bills extra possessions. Falling behind early would make that job considerably harder by allowing Buffalo to stay balanced.
Sharpest Bets Premium
Get our Patriots vs. Bills picks.
Unlock our model's best bets for this matchup, plus projections, trends, and matchup analysis. Start with a free 7-day trial, then save 20% every month with code PREVIEW20.
How the spread shapes the matchup
Buffalo is a seven-point favorite in the current spread, but our one-star side rating points to limited separation around that number despite the Bills’ stronger early-season résumé. The rushing outlook and scoring rate support Buffalo’s case; last week’s five-turnover performance is the obvious counterweight when the market is asking for more than a one-score win.
The scoring environment comes back to the same tension. Buffalo has produced plenty of points through three games, while New England has reached 20 only once. Whether the Patriots can sustain drives—and whether Buffalo protects the ball better than it did last week—will shape both the pace and the number of realistic scoring chances.
Final assessment
Buffalo’s strongest argument is its ability to build the game around a projected rushing advantage and force New England to chase. The Patriots’ counter is ball security: if Maye avoids short-field mistakes and Buffalo’s turnover trouble carries over, the touchdown spread becomes much harder for the favorite to clear. Possession quality is the swing factor, because it determines whether the Bills can steadily press their ground-game edge or whether New England gets the extra opportunities it needs.
We break down every matchup
Want to compare this game with the rest of the Week 4 slate? Visit our NFL betting board for sharp picks, current odds, model projections and matchup ratings across the league.
Odds and projections are snapshots and can change. Wagering involves risk.
More matchups to explore
Unlock our Premium picks. Free.
Get our sharpest picks, team grades, and projected score in your inbox.